Q: Is revenue from online display advertising a dead end for bloggers?

Q: Is revenue from online display advertising a dead end for bloggers?

by Stan Faryna

Stan Faryna

Bruce Springstein, Glory Days

Ron Elwell, CEO of Swoop, an online ad platform, says that engagement has been declining over the last decade.

Engagement rates with display ads are now below .09%.

Elwell means that people are not clicking on banner ads and other display ads like they used to do. In fact, 0.9 percent is a high ball park. Exclude porn, dating, give-aways, and contests, .02% CTR (click through rate) may be the real high ball park.

Low CTR is a challenge that publishers (ad networks and web properties) and advertisers have been struggling to overcome for almost a decade. Elwell doesn’t mention the long road of hope that the onlline ad industry has already walked.

Of course, Publishers and advertisers have long enjoyed the infinite hype and glamour of the intertubes over the last decade. Online advertisers created boundless online presence. Publishers grew, boundlessly.

I believe that the online ad industry took a wrong turn when it trapped the banner ad into unengaging sizes and formats at the top and side bar – not to mention how they put all their think and enthusiasm into clicks and targeting.

Yes, clicks are more interesting than impressions. Of course, clicks is where the money is for publishers – the price for clicks commands a premium when it has always been obvious that the price for impressions had an unfortunate and inevitable destination: $.01 per 1000 impressions.

But they put the banner ad in an untenable position. Where a banner sits on a page and how it sits (size, context, etc.) made it as irrelevant as the irrelevance of the clicks and payoff for all.

Bloggers hoping to build an audience of 1,000,000+ in part so that they eat, pay bills, and keep on keeping on should understand that even if they hit the big numbers and get an ad network signed on, they can only expect ever diminishing returns from an industry that is being shaken.

On the other hand, ad networks have failed to define creative solutions where they can work with the long tail of bloggers (1,000 readers/subscribers per month to 100,000) to improve the contextual platform of the ads they serve and the relevance of those ads to online communities.

Elwell and the others don’t see this.

That’s something that bloggers are going to have to envision and, together, bloggers are going to have to present rich contextual solutions to a reluctant and scornful online advertising industry.

This is an opportunity, bloggers. Don’t let the awesome slip through your fingers.

Stan Faryna
06 March 2012
Bucharest, Romania


If you think that this blog post sucks, let me know in your comment and don’t forget to include a link to YOUR favorite blog post.

If you think this blog post rocks, tell me why it rocks in the comment. “Awesome,””Great post,” etc. works for me. Don’t forget to include a link to YOUR most recent blog post.

Subscribe to this blog if you would enjoy keeping up with my thoughts and commentary. Like it, rate it and share it – if you want to give me some love. Oh yeah – if you have pinsanity, feel free to follow me on Pinterest: http://pinterest.com/faryna


6 Responses to Q: Is revenue from online display advertising a dead end for bloggers?

  1. I see the opportunity, but what is the solution? Truthfully? I don’t think I’ve ever clicked on a banner ad…….even porn………..:).

    I’m probably not a marketers ideal prospect however. Just sayin’….

    • Stan Faryna says:

      I don’t blame you for not clicking on banner ads. But if the big brains of online advertising don’t figure out a way to get people like you to click on the ads, the online display ad thing is going to crash and burn in the next decade. And no one who loves online and free wants that to happen.

  2. Since we are moving away from content, i.e., documents, pictures, et.al. to people on the intertubes I am planning something else.
    A forum/collective were the people can get relevant contact with people they want to develop relationships with and get content that these people produce.
    Inside this compound is a mini webs, of a sort, were all can share the wares they offer under a better system.
    Looking for the end of the year with this…Billy

    • Stan Faryna says:

      Community blogs may be one way in which multiple bloggers can leverage their combined audience for interesting advertising opportunities.

  3. I sure hope they’re not dead ’cause it’s part of my 2012 monetizing strategy (along with several others…absolutely CAN NOT depend on any one source these days)…

Speak from your heart!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: